Plumbing > Water Heater Replacement

Save on Local Plumbing Services

Request Estimate

Request help from a Logan Technician.
Questions? Call us at (800) 564-2611.

"*" indicates required fields

Contact Information*
Address*
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

24/7 service

on All Major Brands

Same-Day

Estimates

Next-Day

Installation

Free

In-Home Estimates

#1

Trane Dealer in Ohio

Why Choose Logan Services for Water Heater Replacement?

We’ve been bringing comfort home since 1969. When you choose Logan Services for your water heater replacement in Ohio, you can expect:

  • Free, same-day estimates and next-day installation
  • A system for every home and budget
  • Licensed, experienced plumbers and technicians
  • Safe, code-compliant removal and replacement
  • Warrantied systems with expert setup

We only install equipment we provide, so your system is guaranteed to work with your space, your needs, and your warranty coverage.

Does replacing a water heater increase your home's value?
2025 Tax Credits Ending Soon!
Schedule Your Water Heater Replacement Before 12/31/2025

Signs You Need to Replace Your Water Heater

Knowing when to replace your water heater can help you avoid costly breakdowns and water damage. Common signs include:

  • Inconsistent or no hot water
  • Water is leaking and pooling near the base of the tank
  • Weak hot water pressure
  • Rust-colored water or a metallic taste
  • Rumbling, popping, or banging noises
  • The unit is 10+ years old
  • Frequent repairs or declining efficiency

If you’re seeing any of these issues, our team of professional plumbers can inspect your system and help you determine if replacement is the best option.

Water Heater Replacement Options

Logan Services offers a full range of replacement systems, including:

Logan Services plumber performing a repair on a standard tank water heater.

Traditional Tank Water Heaters

Reliable, budget-friendly systems that store and heat a set volume of water for daily household use.

Tankless Water Heaters

Compact, energy-efficient units that provide hot water on demand without storing it.

Hybrid Water Heaters

Combine heat pump technology with traditional storage to maximize energy efficiency and reduce utility costs.

Boiler Heating Systems

Dual-purpose systems that supply hot water and radiant heating for homes with hydronic heat setups.

Electric water heaters are ideal for homes without gas service, offering a simple and reliable solution. Gas-powered units provide fast recovery times and typically lower long-term operating costs. For homes with venting limitations, power-vented water heaters use fan-assisted exhaust systems to ensure safe installation. The licensed plumbers at Logan Services will assess your home’s layout, fuel availability, and hot water needs to recommend the best fit for your household.

Our Water Heater Brands

Logan Services installs trusted, high-performance systems from Navien and State Water Heaters to meet Ohio homeowners’ needs. We match each home with the right capacity, venting, and efficiency for safe, reliable hot water.

Navien Tankless Water Heaters

Navien is recognized as a premium brand in the water heating industry because of its advanced technology, long-lasting quality, and commitment to energy efficiency. Their tankless models are engineered to provide endless hot water on demand, while using less energy than traditional systems. As one of the global leaders in condensing technology, Navien designs units that are compact, eco-friendly, and built to deliver performance year after year.

We install Navien’s condensing tankless water heaters, including models with built-in recirculation for faster hot water delivery and flexible configurations that can handle anything from a small home to a large multi-bath household. Navien backs its products with excellent warranty support and readily available replacement parts so that you can count on reliable operation well into the future. When installed by our certified team, your Navien system is set up to meet local code, maximize efficiency, and protect full manufacturer warranty coverage.

Best For: Homeowners seeking continuous hot water, maximum energy savings, and space-saving design.

Common Upgrades We Offer:

  • Whole-home or dedicated recirculation setups
  • High-efficiency venting and condensate management
  • Water quality protection and scale mitigation solutions

State Water Heaters

State Water Heaters is a premium, proven brand known for durable construction, dependable performance, and a wide range of models that fit virtually any home. Their lineup includes gas, electric, power-vent, and high-efficiency options in tall, short, and narrow footprints for tight spaces.

State is trusted by homeowners and contractors alike for its broad parts availability, strong product support, and commitment to safety and efficiency standards. Our certified plumbers ensure every State installation is done to manufacturer specifications and local codes, keeping your system protected under warranty.

Best For: Reliable like-for-like replacements, strong recovery rates, and budget-smart upgrades with trusted warranty support.

Common Upgrades We Provide:

  • Right-sizing tank capacity for household demand
  • Power-vent or direct-vent configurations where required
  • High-efficiency models and mixing valve optimization
  • Expansion tank installation and seismic strapping (where applicable)
  • Water quality protection and sediment/scale mitigation

Tank vs. Tankless Water Heaters

When comparing tank vs. tankless water heater options in Ohio, it helps to look at energy use, hot water demand, available space, and budget.

  • Tankless systems provide unlimited hot water on demand, save energy, and free up floor space with a compact design.
  • Standard Tank units are more affordable upfront and work well for straightforward replacements where a traditional setup already exists.

The table below highlights the key differences to help you decide which option best fits your home. Our plumbing experts will size and install the right system for your home, ensuring reliable hot water and long-term performance.

Feature

Standard Tank Water Heater

Tankless Water Heater

Hot Water Supply

Stores 30–80 gallons for ready use; may run out during heavy demand

Heats water on demand for an unlimited supply

Energy Efficiency

Lower upfront cost, but may use more energy to keep water heated 24/7

Higher efficiency—only heats water when needed

Lifespan

8–12 years

15–20 years

Space Requirements

Requires dedicated floor space

Wall-mounted; frees up floor area

Upfront Cost

More affordable initial purchase and installation

Higher upfront investment

Best For

Homes with moderate hot water needs and consistent usage

Homes with high or unpredictable hot water demand, or limited space

Replacement vs. Repair: What’s the Better Choice?

If your system is still under warranty and the issue is minor, a water heater repair may be the most cost-effective solution. However, if your unit is over 10 years old, leaking, or struggling to deliver consistent hot water, replacement often provides better long-term value and energy savings.

At Logan Services, we evaluate each situation carefully to help you choose between repair and full replacement. Our plumbing experts provide honest guidance based on your system’s condition, performance, and safety, so you can make the best decision for your home.

Schedule Your Water Heater Replacement Today

Don’t wait for a complete breakdown and be stuck without hot water. Let Logan Services replace your aging or broken water heater with a high-performance, energy-efficient model you can count on.

Call (800) 564-2611 or request your free estimate online today. We proudly serve homeowners across central and southern Ohio with fast, friendly, and professional water heater replacement service.

Water Heater Replacement FAQs

How Much Does Water Heater Replacement Cost in Ohio?

Costs vary based on unit type, fuel source, and installation needs. We provide free, up-front estimates that include everything—equipment, labor, permits, and disposal.

Yes. Our team can help you switch between gas, electric, tank, or tankless models, as long as your home’s layout and utility connections support the change.

In most cases, we offer next-day installation across Ohio. Same-day estimates are available to get the process started quickly.

Yes. Removal and responsible disposal of your old unit are always included with our replacement service.

Yes. If your household needs more hot water, we can install a higher-capacity unit—provided your space, plumbing, and venting support the upgrade.

Logan Services offers emergency estimates and next-day replacement to restore hot water quickly. We’ll safely remove the failed unit and install a new one with minimal disruption.

Yes. Replacing an older, inefficient unit with a new ENERGY STAR® model can reduce energy use and operating costs, especially if you’re switching to a high-efficiency or tankless system.

Schedule Water Heater Replacement Today!

Do We Service Your Area?

See Photos Of Our Work And Read Reviews

Logan Services van

Schedule a Free In-Home Estimate with Logan Services Today!

Our team is happy to help! Submit an online inquiry using the form in the button below or give us a call at (800) 564-2611.

We Proudly Serve the Greater Dayton, Cincinnati, and Columbus Areas

Click on the city links to learn more about the local team and find your community on our extensive list of service areas. Have a question? Call any of our locations directly or submit an online inquiry using any of the contact forms on our website. Our team is happy to help!

Select the nearest city:
Dayton, OH HVAC & plumbing company
Dayton

Call Us: (937) 224-3200
Text Us: (937) 421-1486

Logan Services Columbus office
Columbus

Call Us: (614) 224-3200
Text Us: (614) 541-3160

Logan Services Cincinnati office
Cincinnati + NKY

Call Us: (513) 471-3200
Text Us: (513) 813-0802

Ready To Schedule?

Book Online Now!

Schedule a Plumbing Estimate, Repair,
or Maintenance Visit Today!

Same-Day Estimates and Next-Day Installation!*